

You can keep baked buttermilk pie for up to 3 days.īuying buttermilk can be annoying when a recipe only calls for a small amount of it. How long does buttermilk pie last in the fridge? How long does buttermilk pie take to bake?Ībout 40 minutes, then you should let it cool before slicing and serving.

A buttermilk pie has a simple (and addictive) custard-like filling, thanks to eggs, buttermilk, and sugar.ĭo you need to make your own pie crust for buttermilk pie?Ībsolutely not-store-bought pie crust works fine-but we think our classic homemade pie crust is pretty amazing. Typically when you think of pie, you might envision delicious fruit filling, but not here. Buttermilk pie is almost like créme brulee, only wayyy easier to make.
